Plaque 1 at Pittencrieff House

Only on this website, not on any estate agent or council or community websites, is it revealed that purchasers/leaseholders of residential Sovereign Harbour property must pay a unique annual and increasingly expensive flood defence and harbour charge averaging 265 a year in 2018 in addition to council taxes, property insurance, management fees and ground rents. In no other flood area or harbour or marina area or private estate anywhere else in Britain, the UK, Europe or the world does this apply. A much wider flood zone area than just Sovereign Harbour is involved, affecting  more than 17,000 homes, yet the Sovereign Harbour Trust, owned by The Wellcome Trust makes only the 4,300 Sovereign Harbour residents and their successors pay it, to the Environment Agency, not businesses including managing agents and property developers. As Members of Parliament and Eastbourne Borough and East Sussex County councillors have refused to help right this wrong applicable uniquely and solely to Sovereign Harbour residents, the matter has now been referred to overseas agencies . A second unique covenant  requires owners/leaseholders of 369 South Harbour properties in the water feature precinct to pay a further annual charge of 328 in 2018. It is the only such water feature in the world that applies such a charge to properties overlooking it.

General John Forbes established Pittsburgh, PA, USA in 1758

Colonel George Washington was under his command when they celebrated the British military victory over the French

General John Forbes

Gazette news 

Sovereign Harbour

Beaches Council Tax Wrongs Eastbourne Disability Association

Emails

Estate Rent Charge

Forbes Clan Forbes Clan 2 Integrated Council/NHS General John Forbes

July 4 music

July 4 music 2

Pensioners Concerns Property Guidelines Sovereign Ward  

By Keith A. Forbes and his wife Lois Ann Forbes. Both disabled, they now live in Eastbourne, East Sussex and write, administer and webmaster this website. Keith is a member of the UK's The Society of Authors and a consumer activist for the elderly and the disabled. Both authors went to Pittsburgh to research and develop this article. Historical resources in Scotland have indicated General John Forbes shown above and below, who was not married and died childless, was a distant relative via a sibling.

General John Forbes (1707-59)

Also see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Forbes_(British_Army_officer). 

Also see the books:

The British Defeat of the French in Pennsylvania, 1758. Military History of the Forbes Campaign against Fort Duquesne. Douglas R. Cubbison. E-Book.  First Published March 9. 2010. 251 pages. Price sterling 15.04 as a Google E-book or 29.50 in print (Amazon). The first complete military study of the campaign directed by British Army Brigadier General John Forbes to drive the French from the USA. The author details the leadership, logistics, artillery, training and discipline that led to the campaign's success.

General John Forbes book

An extremely interesting book, see above.

John Forbes: Scotland, Flanders and the Seven Years War, 1707-1759.  A new (June 15, 2015) book by John Oliphant. Bloomsbury Publishing. 1st Edition, PDF ebook. 224 pages. ISBN 9781472514127.Bloomsbury Academic. 17 &BW illustrations. US RRP $115.99. Described by Stephen Brumwell, author of George Washington, Gentleman Warrior, "as the first full length biography of a neglected yet highly significant figure in British-American history.'" Based on extensive research on both sides of the Atlantic.

British Brigadier General John Forbes

British General John Forbes, founder of PittsburghCol John Forbes  

General John Forbes and earlier as a Colonel. He was one of the distinguished members of the Forbes Clan of Scotland.

Pittencrieff House, now a museum

Pittencrieff House Museum. Photo taken May 1, 2015 and copyrighted by author Keith Forbes and Lois Forbes during their visit.

He was born on 5 September 5, 1707 (not 1710 as an American account shows) at what was then (since 1701) the family manor home and then-extensive land holdings of Pittencrieff estate, at Pittencrieff House (now a museum) in Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland. He was the second of three sons of Colonel John Forbes a distant cousin of Lord Forbes, and Elizabeth (nee Graham) Forbes. His brothers were Arthur (older, older) who remained at Pittencrieff and Hugh (younger) who later moved to Edinburgh and became a prominent attorney. There have been many John Forbes in history - (including another (later) British Army general who served in India). But this one more than deserves special mention. Forbes (who died 11 March 1759 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, now USA), inscribed his name indelibly and uniquely in both British and American military and geo-political history. 

John Forbes's schoolboy scrawl at Pittencrieff House

As a young boy growing up in the house, he made the inscription shown above:

Pittencrieff House and the Forbes

Plaque 2 at Pittencrieff House

 

Plaque outside house to the General

Details of the plaque to the General

The five photos immediately above of commemorative events outside the house were on May 1, 2015 taken  by authors Keith Forbes and Lois Forbes and are copyrighted.

British Army career

For a much more detailed account of the French and Indian War of the times and the unique role of General John Forbes in it, as the result of which he captured Pittsburgh from the French,  see http://www.historynet.com/french-and-indian-war. 

Scots soldiers were first officially attracted to the British (English) Army when in 1757 in London, Cabinet Minister Mr. Pitt (later, Lord Chatham) recommended to King George II that he employ Highlanders in his service, as the best means of ensuring their loyalty. The king approved the plan and letters of service were immediately drawn up to raise several Highland regiments. Most clans responded positively and many battalions of men signed up, some from the most remote parts of the Highlands. Clan chiefs or their most favored kin obtained commissions.  

Initially, young John Forbes studied medicine, but in his second year as a medical student, decided to become a soldier. He was accepted and commissioned, in 1735, as a lieutenant in the Scots Greys. He saw action in the War of the Austrian Succession. He later served with the British Army in the Jacobite Uprising of 1745 under the infamous Duke of Cumberland. as acting quartermaster-general. A capable and effective soldier, John Forbes won praise from General Lord Ligonier and others. His first significant appointment was as Quartermaster General in the Third British Army of the Duke of Bedford. Later, he served in various campaigns including Louisburg in Canada. General Forbes was 48 years old when he was dispatched to America in command of British soldiers and American troops recruited mostly in Virginia. As an infantry General, he earned his unique claim to fame as a Brigadier General and also as the Commander in Chief of a British Army in which Colonel (later, General and President) George Washington served as his aide. General John Forbes was a genuine British and American hero and made a significant contribution to their military history less than two decades before the American Revolution. He secured a large portion of the United States for the British Crown.  He ensured the military and political future of America's first President. He made it possible for Colonel George Washington, as he was then, to meet his future wife, then the young widow Mrs. Martha Custis, daughter of John Dandridge, a gentleman of Virginia. His mission was to defeat the combined forces of French military units and American Indians who had earlier inflicted a crushing defeat on the valiant but ill fated British General Braddock (whose name was later given to a town in Western Pennsylvania). 

Scottish troops under General John Forbes in USA

 

A British American military hero

British Army of General John Forbes 01British Army of General John Forbes 02British Army of General John Forbes 03 British Army of General John Forbes 04

General Forbes's name is stamped indelibly in the British history of the USA and Pennsylvania. Without him, the vast western lands beyond the Ohio River might never have been settled by English speaking colonists. It was a complex time in conflicting British and French military strategies as they related to America well over two decades before independence from Britain. Although the Treaty of Aix-la-Chapelle of 1748 had concluded the war between Britain and France, it had failed to establish the boundaries of their respective colonies in America. Both nations laid claim to strategic lands around the head waters of the Ohio River, for their rivers flowing into and out of western Pennsylvania that were navigable, long and important.  In 1749 French intentions were to perfect a line of strong military fortifications all the way from French strongholds in Upper Canada on the St. Lawrence River to the mouth of the Mississippi River; in other words from coast to coast. In that year, under French General Celoron, the French Canadians sent an armed party of nearly two hundred men via 23 canoes, from Montreal via the St. Lawrence and Lake Ontario, then overland, to Lake Erie, then overland again, finally to the Allegheny River. There, they demanded that the British Governor of Pennsylvania withdraw all British settlers and military from what they believed was the territory of the French King. When the demand was refused, fighting broke out. Once again, the French and British were enemies, both determined to win their conflicting claims militarily.  In March 1752 the French King appointed Admiral the Marquis Duquesne as Governor of Canada and conduct a war from Montreal and defeat the British and its colonial forces. Initially, that French campaign was successful. General Braddock was the British General first appointed to defend the territory. To supplement his own British troops, including Scottish regiments of foot that had provided garrison duties, he recruited American militia from New York and Pennsylvania. Near what was then Aliquippa (now Pittsburgh), his British troops, not acclimatized to conditions in America, with the equally ill prepared American colonial militia, met up with a huge force of seasoned French veterans, French Canadian militia and their own allies, American Indians - who had been promised all the spoils of war including looting, captured women and more, if they would join in. That battle, on July 9, 1755, was a disaster for General Braddock and his British Americans. Most were captured and butchered by the Indians. They decapitated the Scottish soldiers and comrades and impaled them on poles. Only relatively few Americans and British survived. General Braddock lost his life and his aide, George Washington (pictured below), then 23 years old and at the time a British Army Captain, was lucky to escape capture in the defeat. He observed the battle from a safe distance. The lost battle and its savagery caused an outcry of revulsion - and a demand for revenge, even as the victorious French and Indians dug themselves in. General Forbes exacted that revenge later, even though he was not a well man at the time. His overall leadership and loyalty of his men were key factors as force- marched through Pennsylvania, in one of the most rigorous campaigns ever mounted anywhere in adverse and hostile conditions. 

One of his Highland Regiments, raised in 1757 after the recommendation of Prime Minister Pitt (later, Lord Chatham), was Montgomerie's Highlanders (or 77th Regiment of Foot in official British Army parlance), from the names of its colonel, the Hon. Archibald Montgomerie, son of the Earl of Eglington. A popular man in the Highlands, Montgomerie (later Earl of Eglington and a General in the British Army, colonel-in-chief of the Royal Scots Greys, he died in 1796) personally soon formed into a regiment of thirteen companies of 105 rank and file each, a total of 1,460 effective men, with the requisite number of officers, 65 sergeants and 30 pipers and drummers. The Colonel's commission was dated January 4, 1757. The commissions of the officers were dated each a day later than his senior in the same rank.Montgomerie's Highlanders embarked as a regiment at Greenock for Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada. They were attached to the corps of British Army regulars, including the Royal American provincials under the overall command of Brigadier General Forbes. (They feature prominently in periodic battle reenactments at Fort Ligonier in Pennsylvania). The final British Army military mission of the campaign was to attack and take Fort Duquesne from the French. The inclusion of Montgomerie's Highlanders brought the army of General Forbes to 6238 men in strength. They began in Philadelphia, then a British stronghold.  

George WashingtonGeorge Washington and family

The careful campaign planning yielded one unique, non-military benefit. General Forbes readily granted permission to his aide George Washington, by then an acting Colonel - appointed as such, incidentally by Scots-born Virginia Lieutenant Governor Robert Dinwiddie -  and in command of the Virginia recruited militia, to interrupt briefly his military duties to begin his serious courting of the widow Martha Dandridge Custis, whom he married in 1759. American history says much more about the marriage and life together of George Washington, the lady with whom he had been smitten and married - and his exploits that led to his victories in the American Revolution and election as first President of the United States. Instead, US history seems to give the credit to Washington. Nor has never acknowledged the debt owed by Washington to General John Forbes, which instead of being reciprocated by Washington, led to a serious attempt by Washington to ruin Forbes militarily. This is one of the major omissions in American history. It has also omitted to say that Washington was lucky to escape a court martial, or worse, for directly disobeying General Forbes on at least one occasion, although he later made up for it by faithfully following further orders. Then came the much heralded forced march in 1758, during much of which General Forbes was carried on a litter, struck down by fever, but not so incapacitated that he could not make decisions. The brigadier and his troops reached Raystown, about 90 miles from Fort Duquesne, in September. Major Grant of Montgomerie's Highlanders was sent with 400 of his Highlanders and 500 provincials for a detailed assessment. When near the French fort, Major Grant advanced with pipes playing and drums beating, as if entering a friendly town. The enemy retaliated and were joined by Indians friendly to the French. Protected by thick foliage, they poured destructive fire upon the British. Major Grant tried to force his way into the wood, but was taken in the attempt. On seeing this, his troops dispersed. Only 150 Highlanders returned. More than 231 of them were killed or wounded. The latter included Captain Hugh Mackenzie; Lieutenants Alexander Macdonald, Archibald Robertson and Henry Munro; and Ensigns John Macdonald and Alexander Grant. Near Aliquippa, where the French and Indians had established formidable defenses, he roused himself to take personal command.  

Revenge planned and executed by General Forbes

What he, Colonel Washington and their subordinates saw there, on the French perimeters, was sickening - the skeletons and impaled skulls of the defeated British and American forces led by General Braddock. For some men of less stature it might have been regarded as an omen. For General Forbes it was an outrage that sparked his fiery Scottish soul to heights of fury, to seek and get revenge in full measure. In pincer movements devised by the General himself, the combined British American forces fell on the French and Indians. Seeing the grisly methodology used especially by American, English and Scottish soldiers, the French and Indians were in complete disarray. They left their ammunition, military hardware and provisions as prizes for the British and American troops. The British Army inflicted such a complete defeat in October 1758 that the French campaign was never again attempted. Officers of Montgomerie's Highlanders Killed at Fort Duquesne included Captains William Macdonald and George Munro; Lieutenants Colin Campbell, Alexander Macdonald, Alexander Mackenzie and William Mackenzie. Many more are unaccounted for. On November 25, 1758, General Forbes and Colonel Washington stood side by side as their troops marched into Aliquippa, to take formal possession of the land where two rivers - the Monongahela and Allegheny - meet to form a mighty third - the Ohio. At this place, they renamed the small town, originally the name of a ruling Indian Queen. 

Forbes Road from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh

General Forbes campaign 2 General Forbes campaign 2

Fightng Duquesne 01 General John Forbes was here in 1758

Capture of Aliquippa, later Pittsburgh PA. Right image shows Fort Ligonier in Pennsylvania, one site of his campaign for victory.

Staff officers with General Forbes were young and ambitious. Archibald Montgomery was also from Scotland. Henry Bouquet (of Montgomerie's Highlanders) was from Scotland and Switzerland. Others included John Armstrong, Joseph Shippen (a Princeton graduate and member of a prominent Philadelphia family), Harry Gordon - a noted military engineer, William Byrd, George Mercer of Virginia, George Croghan and John Ormsby. It was an impressive sight as the newly arrived army, wearing brilliant uniforms, marched in four columns, with flags flying and drums beating. They reached the camping ground, halted and took possession, while Colonel John Armstrong raised the flag, the Union Jack, over the British territory.

Forbes Road named after the general

General John Forbes duly claimed, in his own words, "this prodigious tract of fine, rich country" in the name of his king. He and his army of several thousand had marched over rough, rugged Allegheny mountains and endured much in the way of hazards and hardships. The progress had been slow as a road - Forbes Road - had to be built ahead of them.  It was bitter cold and as a special favor, an order was issued from the General that every working soldier could have, daily, a gill of spirits, diluted with water. November 25, 1758, was of such great importance that London rejoiced and both New York and Philadelphia joined in the celebrations with military parades of their own. An American military historian recorded the event thus:  "As the banner of England floated over the waters, the place, at the suggestion of General Forbes, was with one voice called Pittsburgh. It is the most enduring monument to the famous English statesman William Pitt, the Peacemaker. Long as the Monongahela and Allegheny shall flow to form the Ohio; long as the English tongue shall be the language of freedom in the boundless valley which their waters traverse, his name shall stand inscribed on the Gateway of the West." 

He was one of the most renowned military heroes in the history of the Forbes Clan.

Subsequent events

Forbes Memorial, Christ Church, Philadelphia General John Forbes was buried here in 1759 Christchurch, Philadelphia, today

On Sunday morning December 3, 1758, in a very ill state and on a litter, General Forbes left Pittsburgh with a large staff, including the Highlanders, and returned by slow, painful stages to Philadelphia. He died there on March 11, 1759.  He was a bachelor, with no children but with family including brothers and a sister living in Dunfermline, Scotland. He was buried in Christ Churchyard, at 2nd and Market Streets.  See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christ_Church,_Philadelphia. It was the first Episcopal church in the USA. He was only 49 years old. He never went home to Scotland.  Ironically, it was only during his funeral in Philadelphia that his command received official notification from England that he had been appointed a full General of the British Army. (By contrast, Washington had a much longer and luckier life. He served as the first President of the United States from 1789 to 1797. mOn his death in 1799, he was land rich, with 70,000 acres in Virginia and 40,000 acres in West Virginia).

The name "Duquesne" lives on, as an area of Pittsburgh, approached from the city end of Forbes Street. Duquesne University is a prominent building there, one of the many universities in Pittsburgh. The "military" Forbes Road from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh was mapped in 2002 by the Somerset Archeology Society of Pennsylvania. Mapping started at Fort Duart at the top of the Allegheny Mountain in Somerset County. Contact Georgia Sheftic, Somerset Archeology Society, 28ll Lincoln Highway, Stoystown, PA 15563, USA.

Photo right: Forbes Memorial, Christ Church, Philadelphia

General Forbes Monument at Pittsburgh's Point State Park and footnotes

Visitors to the attractive city of Pittsburgh are welcomed. They can see the impressive monument (shown below) to General John Forbes, founder of the city, so-named by him in honour of his hero William Pitt the Younger, Prime Minister of the United Kingdom in 1758. Pittsburgh, well-served by air, a regional hub, and by train and road, is not at all the smoky steel city it once was, but is now in many places a glass palace following extensive economic redevelopment of many areas following the departure of the steel mills and their related industries.  Today, it is the home base or regional centre of many leading US regional, national and multi-national companies.  (corporations) either based or with offices in the city.  The monument is where he and George Washington once stood. It is at Point State Park where the Allegheny and Monongahela rivers, separate up to that point, both feeding Pittsburgh, meet. They form the huge Ohio River, which connects ultimately with and becomes part of the mighty Mississippi River.   Pittsburgh also has a long boulevard named Forbes Street, again to commemorate this General John Forbes. It stretches for miles, in various stages of affluence, from near Point State Park, through downtown Pittsburgh, nearly as far as Wilkinsburg.   There is a Forbes Road from Carlisle to Pittsburgh built by the troops of General Forbes. (There are many streets or roads in America named after a Forbes, but this one is very special). The monument above pays tribute to the man who spent only a year in Pennsylvania and died and was buried at a relatively young age in Philadelphia. A further testament to him and his military campaign is at Ligonier, Pennsylvania. Volume XXXV No. 4 (October 1978) of the William and Mary Quarterly, published by the Institute of Early American History and Culture, Williamsburg, Virginia.  Also see a great deal about General John Forbes  in "Redcoats in the Wilderness: British Officers and Irregular Warfare in Europe and America, 1740 to 1760" by Peter E. Russell.

General John Forbes Memorial, Pittsburgh PA

Photograph of the General John Forbes Memorial in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, taken personally by Keith and Lois Forbes, when the authors were there. At one point, this author, Keith Forbes lived in Pittsburgh, not far from Forbes Road.

Footnotes

John P.Finnigan, at email Oldhikemaster1@WMconnect.com wrote:

" I have a written a Booklet "The Hike Master's Guide to the Forbes Road" - Fort Bedford to Fort Ligonier. It  describes 7 one day walks of about 10 miles. Much of the information has been accumulated in 33 3-ring Binders, collected from researchers' notes and maps of their collections that were given to me. My Boy Scout Troop and myself, Fred Colley and others spent time locating the scars they recorded in the 1920's and 30's, and in 1968 the Hiking Trail was established for the 1976 Bi-Centennial Hiking Program of Penn's Woods Council over it. As the years have passed, more and more of those scars are being destroyed. I hope the booklets will help to keep General  John Forbes in the place to which he belongs in history, since now the History Books give one paragraph. My Research Library would fill a room if displayed."

Co. Sgt. Major Malcolm MacWilliam, 77th Reg't of Foote, Grenadiers (Mark Hagenbuch) email manyflags@adelphia.net wrote:

"I am an 18th century re-enactor of the 77th Regiment of Foot, Montgomerie's Highlanders, Grenadier company.  At Christ Church, Philadelphia, our regiment  laid a wreath at General Forbes's crypt and conducted a ceremony of mourning. The ceremony was conducted with full 18th century military honours, the 77th lads were in full uniform with accoutrements and weapons."

Recent Tributes to General John Forbes

In his hometown of Dunfermline, Scotland, there was a fabulous General Forbes Day event (see image below) on April 5, 2014 organized mostly by local historian Frank Connelly, when a special ceremony. complete with a unique Forbes Marker marking and commemorating his American exploits his  took place at the former home of General Forbes, at Pittencrieff House, Coal Road, Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland. Sadly, his death from his American campaign had disastrous financial implications for his family members. They had to sell their home, built new in 1650 and acquired by them in about 1701.  But there is a happier ending to the story. Much later, it was bought by another distinguished gentleman from Dunfermline, Andrew Carnegie, who as a boy had once been forbidden by the later laird of the manor to play in the grounds. Carnegie donated the house and lands, now Pittencrieff House Museum and Pittencrieff Park respectively, to Dunfermline.

At Pittencrieff House Museum, a Forbes Marker was unveiled with actors taking the part of Carnegie and Forbes. And in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania,  the city's daily newspaper, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette,  wrote this piece - see Pittsburgh-Gazette Post - about the Dunfermline and Pittsburgh connections arising from both General John Forbes and celebrated philanthropist Andrew Carnegie.

General Forbes Day in Dunfermline

Also, the lovely city of Sarasota, Florida - one of the nicest places in the USA in which to live - was founded by Scots including from Dunfermline. The latter is one of the seven sister-cities of Sarasota, see http://www.sarasotasistercities.org/en/city/dunfermline-scotland

Keith also writes

Bermuda Online (BOL) Banner 2a

Websites written, administered, designed, mostly photographed and web-mastered by

Email.gif (14893 bytes)

Keith A. Forbes and Lois A Forbes at editor@sovereignharbourgazette.org.uk  
2018. Revised: November 2, 2018